Bandar still alive, insiders say
http://www.aspentimes.com/article/20120824/NEWS/120829914
ASPEN - Prince Bandar bin Sultan, chief of Saudi Arabia's intelligence
agency and still an Aspen property owner, is apparently alive and well
despite rumors in early August that he had been assassinated in an
explosion.
A spokesman for the U.S.
State Department on Wednesday said recent stories reporting that Bandar,
63, had been killed were not true.
David
Ottaway, who retired from the Washington Post in 2006 after 30 years of
covering Saudi Arabia, also says the stories were false.
"If
Bandar had died, the government would have announced it," Ottaway said.
"It would not be possible to hide such a death, even in Saudi Arabia. I
do not believe he has died, but I have not seen him in public since he
took his new job."
Ottaway is the
author of the 2008 book "The King's Messenger: Prince Bandar bin Sultan
and America's Tangled Relationship with Saudi Arabia."
"The
Iranians are constantly putting out stories through their agents of
some mishap about Bandar that have been all false so far," Ottaway wrote
Thursday in response to an email query.
Additionally,
David Ignatius, a veteran foreign-affairs columnist with the Washington
Post, reported on Aug. 5 that the rumors of Bandar's death were false.
This week, Ignatius confirmed that his source on Bandar was solid.
"Yes,
before I wrote my piece on Aug. 5, I talked with a source who
confirmed, based on personal knowledge, Prince Bandar had been in
regular phone contact with foreign officials that week to discuss
intelligence matters," Ignatius wrote in response to an email query.
Further
evidence of Bandar's continued existence also came on Aug. 14, when the
Saudi Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued a statement that noted that
Bandar was in attendance at the Islamic Solidarity Summit being held in
Mecca.
And on Aug. 15, the Qatar News
Agency reported that Bandar had escorted the emir of Qatar to the
airport in Jeddah after the first day of the summit.
Bandar, who served as Saudi ambassador to the U.S. from 1983 to 2005, built a lavish estate in Aspen in 1991.
In
June, he sold his main home and another nearby residence in the
Starwood neighborhood to hedge-fund billionaire John Paulson for $49
million. In 2007, Bandar sold another Starwood home for $36 million.
But
Bandar owned four homes in Starwood, and he still owns a relatively
modest 5,200-square-foot home valued at $5.2 million by the Pitkin
County assessor.
The home is listed
as being owned by Bricol NV, an entity controlled by Bandar and managed
by attorney William Jordan III, who did not respond to a request for
comment.
After several years of
keeping a low profile, Bandar suddenly made international headlines in
the past five weeks and became the subject of wide speculation, perhaps
as the result of a deliberate misinformation campaign.
The
tale starts on July 18, when a suicide bomber was able to detonate an
explosion at Syria's National Security Headquarters in Damascus, killing
the Syrian defense minister and the deputy defense minister, who was
also President Bashar Assad's brother-in-law. The Free Syrian Army
claimed responsibility.
The next day,
July 19, Bandar, already secretary general of the Saudi National
Security Council, also was named chief of intelligence by King Abdullah.
That prompted speculation by some
media outlets that Bandar's additional intelligence role was a reward
for the Syrian bombing. The Saudis have urged military intervention in
the Syrian conflict against the Assad regime.
On
July 22, Iran's English-language Press TV ran a story headlined "Blast
hits Saudi intelligence building, killing deputy spy chief."
The
Press TV story said Bandar's deputy had been killed. The Iranian story
said that Yemen's al-Fajr Press had quoted eyewitnesses to the bombing,
which has not been reported in the Western media.
On
July 29, the website of the Voltaire Network, a pro-Syrian nonprofit
organization, upped the ante and ran a story headlined "Syria reportedly
eliminated Bandar bin Sultan in retaliation for Damascus bombing."
"Though
not yet announced by the Saudi authorities, the death of Prince Bandar
bin Sultan bin Abdulaziz Al Saud has been confirmed to Voltaire Network
by unofficial sources," the story claimed.
The next day, the Voltaire Network appeared to walk the story back a notch.
"Strangely,
Saudi authorities have not responded to inquiries by the media,
refusing to confirm or deny the death of their newly appointed chief of
the intelligence services. Clearly, regardless of whether the prince is
dead or alive, such muteness denotes a serious disarray within the Saudi
royal family," an article stated.
But by then, the rumor of Bandar's death was off to the races.
On
July 31, The International Business Times News ran a story with the
headline "Prince Bandar bin Sultan: Is the Saudi spy chief dead or
alive?"
The same day, Iran's Press
TV ran a report titled "Saudi spy chief Prince Bandar assassinated,
report says" and cited the Voltaire Network as the source.
The
managing editor of The Aspen Times noticed the stories and ran a short
column on Aug. 1 labeled "commentary" about the rumors of Bandar's
death.
The next day, the Times
published a second commentary on the "Bandar mystery," admitting the
paper was "utterly clueless on this one."
Iran's
Press TV saw the Times commentaries, and an Iranian television host
noted during an interview on Aug. 4 that "We've also got the local paper
in Aspen, Colo., wondering what is the fate of one of their famous
residents, Prince Bandar of Saudi Arabia, who owns a condo in Aspen, who
hasn't been seen for the last week or two. There are reports that he
succumbed to an attack on his headquarters."
But the same day, some push-back on the rumor came from Saudi Arabia.
A
piece by Ali Bluwi in Arab News - said to be aligned with the Saudi
royal family - denounced the rumors of Bandar's death Aug. 4 as "Iranian
and Syrian propaganda."
The article said the source of the rumors was the man behind the Voltaire Network, Thierry Meyssan.
"Usually
there is a lot of fabricated news about personalities of Bandar's
caliber, and that has been the case now," the article stated.
The next day, the Voltaire Network acknowledged the Aug. 4 story in Arab News.
"Taking
note of the information relayed by Arab News on the activities of
Prince Bandar, Voltaire Network wishes him a speedy recovery and
expressed the hope that no formal commitments will crop up to interfere
with his convalescence," a story on Voltairenet.org said.
Also
on Aug. 5, Post columnist Ignatius wrote that the rumor of Bandar's
death "was rebutted Friday by a source who said that Bandar had been in
telephone contact with non-Saudis."
Then came the official statements from the Saudi and Qatar governments placing Bandar in Mecca and Jeddah in mid-August.
Since
then, the speculation about Bandar's death has quieted, but there have
been no stories confirming that he is, in fact, alive.
Wednesday's
statement from a State Department spokesperson appears to be the first
acknowledgment from a U.S. official that the reports earlier this month
of Bandar's death were in fact false.
Moscow ‘rejects’ Saudi ‘offer’ to drop Assad for rich arms deal
Russia Today — August 8, 2013
Moscow
has said “no” to Saudi Arabia’s alleged proposal of a rich arms deal
and protection of Russia’s gas interests in the Middle East in exchange
for abandoning Syrian President Bashar Assad, according to Arab and
European diplomats.
The proposal of $15 billion in weapons
contracts was allegedly made during the July 31 meeting between Russian
President Vladimir Putin and influential intelligence chief Prince
Bandar bin Sultan, Reuters reported.
Neither Moscow nor Riyadh has officially commented on the agenda of the talks, but a Thursday AFP report revealed new details of the negotiations.
According to an undisclosed European diplomat, Prince Bandar proposed the deal and told Putin that “whatever regime comes after” Assad will be “completely” in Riyadh’s hands. The Prince reportedly stated that if the deal was accepted, Saudi Arabia would not sign any contracts damaging Russian interests by allowing Gulf countries to transport its gas across Syria to Europe.
The terms included Moscow dropping its support of President Bashar Assad, as well as not opposing any future Security Council resolutions on Syria.
“President Putin listened politely to his interlocutor and let him know that his country would not change its strategy,” a separate Arab diplomat told AFP.
Bandar bin Sultan then told Russian officials that the only option left in Syria is a military one – and that they should forget about the Geneva-2 international peace conference because the opposition would not attend, the source said. Efforts to bring about the conference – which has been put forth by the US and Moscow – have so far been fruitless, mainly because of the absence of unity within the opposition ranks.
Neither Moscow nor Riyadh has officially commented on the agenda of the talks, but a Thursday AFP report revealed new details of the negotiations.
According to an undisclosed European diplomat, Prince Bandar proposed the deal and told Putin that “whatever regime comes after” Assad will be “completely” in Riyadh’s hands. The Prince reportedly stated that if the deal was accepted, Saudi Arabia would not sign any contracts damaging Russian interests by allowing Gulf countries to transport its gas across Syria to Europe.
The terms included Moscow dropping its support of President Bashar Assad, as well as not opposing any future Security Council resolutions on Syria.
“President Putin listened politely to his interlocutor and let him know that his country would not change its strategy,” a separate Arab diplomat told AFP.
Bandar bin Sultan then told Russian officials that the only option left in Syria is a military one – and that they should forget about the Geneva-2 international peace conference because the opposition would not attend, the source said. Efforts to bring about the conference – which has been put forth by the US and Moscow – have so far been fruitless, mainly because of the absence of unity within the opposition ranks.
Russia and Saudi Arabia – which
traditionally buys its military hardware from the US – have had a
massive arms contract frozen since 2008. Back then, the sides agreed
that Moscow would supply a huge assortment of equipment, including 150
T-90 tanks and more than 150 attack helicopters, to the Gulf state.
According
to sources within Russian arms exporters, the status of the deal has
not changed following the talks. The insider added that Russia has not
received any offers to purchase weapons from Saudi Arabia.
“We know nothing about such intentions of the Saudi side,” a senior source in military-technical cooperation told RIA Novosti news agency.
“We know nothing about such intentions of the Saudi side,” a senior source in military-technical cooperation told RIA Novosti news agency.
Some Russian experts say Saudi Arabia
acted as a US proxy in the alleged proposal, as it has been doing for
the past two years of the Syrian conflict.
“Any direct involvement in the
region by either the US or any former European colonial powers is
perceived as an affront. But with the given arrangement, any initiatives
by the influential, authoritarian regional super power (and Saudi
Arabia is undoubtedly that) are taken for granted,” political analyst Igor Khokhlov told RT.
“The situation is nothing new,” he added. “Gulbuddin
Hekmatyar’s Afghan mujahideen in the 1980s were being sponsored by the
USA and Saudi Arabia in equal shares. But the Saudi role allowed the US
to present the conflict as a war of liberation – not as a clash of two
superpowers in the farthest reaches of the world.”
Others believe the media reports of a
Saudi offer is nothing more than a hoax aimed at highlighting Russia’s
stance on Syria in a negative way, adding that such a method is no way
to “conduct diplomacy.”
“Clearly, this is stove-piping,” director of the Institute of Oriental Studies, Vitaly Naumkin, told Interfax news agency. “Its
purpose is either to influence the position of the Syrian authorities
or, more likely, to discredit Russia. To sow doubt on the fact that
Moscow has a serious and reasoned position on Syria, and to create the
impression that Russia may change its point of view in exchange for
Saudi promises.”
Naumkin reminded that similar attempts were made previously. There were reports in 2009 of that Barack Obama told then-Russian President Dmitry Medvedev that Washington would change its position on Iran if Moscow ended the halting of a US missile shield program in Eastern Europe.
The meeting between Putin and Bandar came amid tension between the two states over the conflict in Syria, with Russia accusing the Saudis of “financing and arming terrorists and extremist groups” fighting against Assad.
Naumkin reminded that similar attempts were made previously. There were reports in 2009 of that Barack Obama told then-Russian President Dmitry Medvedev that Washington would change its position on Iran if Moscow ended the halting of a US missile shield program in Eastern Europe.
The meeting between Putin and Bandar came amid tension between the two states over the conflict in Syria, with Russia accusing the Saudis of “financing and arming terrorists and extremist groups” fighting against Assad.
RUSIA TOLAK RAYUAN SAUDI UNTUK TINGGALKAN SYRIA
http://cahyono-adi.blogspot.com/2013/08/rusia-tolak-rayuan-saudi-untuk.html#.Ugd60lIxVkg
Rusia menolak rayuan Saudi untuk meninggalkan sekutunya, Syria, meski
Saudi mengiming-imingi imbalan besar. Imbalan tersebut berupa paket
pembelian senjata miliaran dolar serta jaminan kepentingan bisnia gas
Rusia di Timur Tengah. Demikian laporan media Rusia, Russia Today, Jumat (9/8), mengutip keterangan beberapa diplomat Rusia dan Arab.
Proposal pembelian senjata senilai $15 miliar serta jaminan kepentingan bisnis tersebut disampaikan oleh kepala inteligen Saudi Bandar bin Sultan saat menemui Presiden Rusia Vladimir Putin tgl 31 Juli lalu. Baik pejabat Rusia maupun Saudi bungkam mengenai informasi tersebut, namun kantor berita Perancis AFP hari Kamis (8/8) melaporkan secara mendetil pertemuan tersebut.
Menurut laporan tersebut Pangeran Bandar meminta Putin untuk menyetujui Arab Saudi untuk menentukan masa depan kepemimpinan Syria setelah Bashar al Assad. Dan sebagai imbalannya Saudi berjanji untuk tidak melakukan kontrak bisnis yang merugikan kepentingan Rusia dengan cara mengalirkan migas negara-negara Teluk ke Eropa melalui Syria. Adapun syarat yang diajukan Bandar adalah agar Rusia menghentikan
dukungannya terhadap regim Bashar al Assad, termasuk tidak memblok resolusi DK PBB yang akan diterapkan terhadap Syria.
“Presiden Putin mendengarkan dengan tenang perkataan lawan bicaranya dan menjelaskan bahwa sikap negara Rusia tidak berubah," tulis AFP mengutip pernyataan seorang diplomat Arab.
Bandar bin Sultan selanjutnya mengatakan kepada para pejabat Rusia bahwa solusi yang tersisa atas konflik Syria adalah penyelesaian militer seraya menambahkan bahwa pemberontak tidak akan hadir dalam pertemuan Genewa II, sehingga rencana tersebut dipastikan akan batal.
Sejauh ini rencana perundingan Genewa II memang diragukan akan berlangsung seperti diharapkan karena ketidak kompakan pemberontak dan posisi mereka yang tengah berada di bawah angin yang membuat perundingan dianggap tidak akan menguntungkan mereka dan negara-negara sponsornya.
Saudi Arabia yang secara tradisi mengandalkan persenjataannya dari Amerika, sejak tahun 2008 memiliki sejumah besar kontrak pembelian senjata dari Rusia yang dibekukan, di antaranya pembelian 150 tank T-90 dan 150 helikopter serbu. Dengan gagalnya pertemuan Bandar-Putin tersebut, dipastikan kontrak tersebut tidak berubah statusnya.
Beberapa pengamat politik Rusia menganggap upaya Pangeran Bandar tersebut hanya kepanjangan tangan Amerika belaka, sebagaimana telah dilakukan beberapa kali sebelumnya sejak konflik Syria pecah lebih dari 2 tahun lalu.
"Situasinya tidak berbeda dengan dahulu. Pemimpin mujahidin Afghanistan Gulbuddin Hekmatyar didukung oleh USA dan Saudi Arabia bersama-sama. Namun peran Saudi memungkinkan Amerika mengkampanyekan perang Afganistan sebagai "perang pembebasan", bukan perang antar 2 negara superpower,” kata analis politik Igor Khokhlov kepada Russia Today.
Pengamat lainnya menganggap upaya Pangeran Bandar sebagai langkah "tipuan" untuk mengesankan adanya ketidakstabilan sikap Rusia atas Syria.
Hubungan Rusia-Saudi sendiri kini berada dalam kondisi "dingin" setelah kedua pihak saling menuduh dalam konflik Syria. Terakhir Rusia menuduh Saudi telah membiayai dan mempersenjatai para teroris di Syria.
REF:
"Moscow ‘rejects’ Saudi ‘offer’ to drop Assad for rich arms deal"; Russia Today; 8 AgustUS 2013
SERANGAN BALASAN SYRIA/IRAN TEWASKAN PANGERAN BANDAR?
http://cahyono-adi.blogspot.com/2012/07/serangan-balasan-syriairan-tewaskan.html#more
Baik serangan maupun kematian pemimpin tertinggi inteligen Saudi ini belum mendapatkan konfirmasi dari penguasa Saudi. Media-media barat juga menutup rapat-rapat kabar serangan tersebut. Namun media Iran, juga media-media independen ramai-ramai memberitakan kabar tersebut.
Menurut media online Perancis Voltaire Network (voltairenet.org), serangan terhadap kantor inteligen Saudi tersebut merupakan aksi balasan atas serangan bom yang menewaskan 4 pejabat tinggi keamanan Syria di Damaskus tgl 18 Juli 2012.
Voltaire Network benar. Bahkan serangan balasan itu bukan yang pertama. Sebelumnya dikabarkan konvoi menhan Israel Ehud Barak diserang roket yang ditembakkan dari Syria, namun tidak melukai Barak namun cukup untuk membuatnya "shock".
Sebagaimana diberitakan di media-media independen dan media-media massa Iran, sebuah serangan bom telah menghancurkan markas inteligen Arab Saudi di Riyadh, 23 Juli lalu, menewaskan orang kedua badan inteligen Saudi, Mashaal al-Qarni dan diduga kuat melukai parah dan kemudian menewaskan Pangeran Bandar bin Sultan, pimpinan tertinggi badan inteligen Saudi yang baru diangkat oleh Raja Saudi tgl 19 Juli lalu, atau selang sehari setelah serangan bom di Damaskus Syria yang menewaskan 4 pejabat tinggi keamanan Syria.
Kabar tentang serangan tersebut sama sekali tidak mendapat tempat di media-media "mapan" internasional. Pun pemerintah Saudi tidak memberikan komentarnya tentang peristiwa tersebut, tidak membantah dan juga tidak membenarkannya, meski faktanya Pangeran Bandar dan Al Qarni tidak pernah lagi muncul di hadapan publik setelah peristiwa serangan tersebut.
Adalah DEBKAfile, media online Isreal yang dikenal dekat dengan kalangan inteligen Israel dan barat, yang pertama kali melaporkan serangan bom tersebut tgl 26 Juli lalu, disusul oleh media-media massa Iran serta media-media independen internasional.
Pangeran Bandar, salah seorang pejabat tinggi Arab Saudi paling senior dan dikenal memiliki hubungan luas dengan para pemimpin barat, termasuk dua Presiden Bush senior dan junior. Ia juga pernah terlibat kasus suap terbesar sepanjang sejarah dengan menerima komisi senilai miliaran dolar dari perusahaan produsen senjata Inggris. Namun kasus ini menguap begitu saja.
Mantan dubes Saudi untuk Amerika, Pangeran Bandar adalah putra dari raja Saudi terdahulu. Ia diangkat sebagai kepala inteligen Saudi hanya sehari setelah serangan bom di Damaskus tgl 18 Juli, menambah jabatan strategis lainnya setelah sebelumnya menduduki jabatan sebagai Ketua Dewan Keamanan Nasional Saudi sejak tahun 2005. Kemungkinan pengangkatan itu sebagai balas jasa atas perannya dalam serangan di Damaskus, tidak heran jika ia menjadi sasaran paling dicari Syria dan sekutunya, Iran, untuk balas dendam. Bandar yang menjalin hubungan dekat dengan inteligen Israel juga diduga kuat berada di balik kematian pejabat-pejabat Palestina dan Hizbollah yang tewas melalui serangan terorisme.
Para analis inteligen meragukan Syria memiliki kemampuan untuk menembus sistem keamanan super ketat keluarga kerajaan Saudi. Namun Iran memiliki kemampuan tersebut. Antara tahun 2003-2004 Iran berhasil melakukan serangkaian serangan bom di Saudi Arabia dengan menggunakan Al Qaida sebagai operatornya. Salah seorang anggota Al Qaida yang menjalankan operasi tersebut adalah Saif al-Adal, yang kini menetap di Pakistan. Kemampuan Iran memperalat Al Qaida untuk menyerang Saudi merupakan kesuksesan besar inteligen Iran mengingat secara idiologis Al Qaida yang salafis dan binaan CIA-Saudi, memusuhi Iran yang Shiah.
Arti strategis Syria bagi Iran membuat Iran akan melakukan apapun untuk mempertahankan regim Bashar al Assad. Selain itu kemampuan Iran melakukan serangan ke jantung Saudi menjadi peringatan bahwa "tangan Iran cukup panjang untuk menghukum musuh-musuhnya". Pemboman Damaskus tgl 18 Juli telah memaksa konflik Syria melebar keluar.
Kabar tentang meninggalnya Pangeran Bandar akibat serangan yang melukainya muncul hari MInggu, 29 Juli lalu. Kabar ini menggema sangat keras meski tidak ada konfirmasi resmi, justru karena momentumnya yang sangat "tepat": pemboman Damaskus tgl 18 Juli, pengangkatan Pangeran Bandar sebagai kepala inteligen tgl 19 Juli, dan serangan bom Riyadh empat hari kemudian. Diamnya pemerintah Saudi semakin menambah kuat kabar kematian tersebut.
KOMANDAN-KOMANDAN PEMBERONTAK TEWAS DI ALEPPO
Sementara itu media massa Perancis, "Le Figaro", hari Senin (30/7) melaporkan bahwa sebagian besar komandan pemberontak di Aleppo telah tewas dalam pertempuran melawan pasukan pemerintah Syria di kota terbesar Syria tersebut.
Reporter Adrian Golms, yang memasuki Aleppo melalui perbatasan Turki melaporkan terjadinya perang hebat di kawasan Salah al-Din, Aleppo, yang menewaskan "sejumlah besar komandan pemberontak".
Menurut laporan tersebut para pemberontak, yang sebagiannya adalah sisa-sisa pasukan pemberontak yang terdesak di Damaskus dan Homs, berhasil merebut beberapa kawasan kota Aleppo meski gagal merebut sebagian kawasan lainnya dari pasukan keamanan Syria. Mereka juga gagal memaksa penduduk untuk membantu mereka menghadapi serangan militer Syria yang mengepung Aleppo.
Ref:
"Saudi silence on intelligence chief Bandar’s fate denotes panic"; DEBKAfile Special Report, 31 Juli 201
"Saudi spy chief Prince Bandar assassinated, report says"; Press TV; 31 Juli 2012
"Large Number of Armed Groups’ Leaders killed by Syrian Army in Aleppo"; almanar.com.lb; 31 Juli 2012